Perspective
No. 03 · November 2026

The Same Factory
Makes Your Product
and Your Competitor's

In South Florida, the line that fills your bottle can fill the one beside it, and the law prints your formula on the back. What a supplement brand owns is what a shopper believes about it.

The factory down the road

On 21 October, CUNSA International announced a new production facility in Miami. The company is based in Hialeah, and it makes private-label dietary supplements for customers around the world. It has neighbors in the same trade. In Davie, Arnet Pharmaceutical runs a 135,000 square foot plant and offers brands an "extensive catalog of pre-formulated stock formulas" ready for their own name. In Fort Lauderdale, Sun Nutraceuticals tells founders they can "build on a Sun-developed base formula and apply their own branding."

This is a good system, and I want to say that plainly. It lets a founder launch a first capsule without building a plant, and it puts testing and equipment within reach of a small brand. Follow it one step further, though. A catalog formula exists to be offered to more than one brand. The base that goes into your bottle this spring can go into another founder's bottle by summer, with a different label around the same capsule. Nobody has done anything wrong when that happens, because the model is working the way it was designed to.

One line runs the formula. The label decides whose it is.

The recipe is printed on the back

Then there's the label. Federal rules require a Supplement Facts panel that lists the amount by weight, per serving, of each dietary ingredient. A proprietary blend can hold back the individual amounts, but it still has to list its ingredients in descending order by weight and state the blend's total weight. Whatever a founder worked out with a formulator ends up readable in the aisle, by anyone holding the bottle, including the next founder who already has a manufacturer.

The rules print one more thing. When the company named on the label didn't make the product, its name has to carry a phrase such as "Manufactured for" or "Distributed by." A shopper learns what's inside and who's selling it. Where it was made never has to appear. Two bottles can come off the same line in Hialeah, and nothing on either one has to say so.

The back of the bottle prints the recipe and leaves out the kitchen.

A better formula is the easiest thing to copy

The instinct is to answer this with the formula: raise a dose, or add a branded ingredient. Both are real improvements, and both print themselves on the back of the bottle the day it ships. The better formula becomes the brief the next brand sends to its manufacturer.

None of this makes the founder's job smaller. FDA's compliance guide for supplement makers says a distributor that has someone else manufacture its product, and sells it under its own label, has "an obligation to know what and how manufacturing activities are performed," and decides whether each batch is released. The brand carries the responsibility for the product, whoever runs the line. That care is the price of being on the shelf at all, and a shopper standing in the aisle can't see any of it.

So the founder holds everything that's expensive, the specifications and the release decision, and owns very little that a shopper can tell apart from the bottle beside it. That gap is where most of the work is.

Belief stays with the name on the front

In the Council for Responsible Nutrition's 2024 consumer survey, conducted by Ipsos, 71% of supplement users said they're loyal to the brands they choose. That loyalty attaches to a name. The panel tells a shopper what's in the bottle, and her trust goes to whoever is named on the front. Products don't win. Belief does.

Belief comes from what a shopper can't read off the panel: why this founder chose these ingredients, and whether the story on the first bottle is still true on the fifth. A manufacturer can run your capsule for anyone who calls. It has no way to run the reason your customer picked you.

The direction is visible in the factories themselves. A new production floor opened in Miami this autumn to make supplements for brands, and every new line makes a formula a little easier to produce. One facility doesn't settle a market. It does tell you which part of your brand is getting cheaper to make, and which part isn't.

So turn your bottle around and read the panel the way the next founder will. Everything they'd need to make your product is printed there, and a manufacturer in South Florida can run it. Now put your hand over the panel. What's left on that bottle that the next founder couldn't order from the same line?

The same factory makes your product and your competitor's. Anyone can make what you make. Only you can make them believe it.

Everything above the yellow line can be copied.

What to do with this on Monday

Read your panel the way a competitor would. Hand your bottle to someone on your team and ask them to write the brief they'd send a manufacturer to make it. However long that takes is how long your formula is yours.

Ask your manufacturer one plain question. Find out whether your base formula sits in their catalog or was made for you alone, and get the answer in writing. Either answer is workable once you know which one you're building on.

Write down what the factory can't run. List what a shopper believes about you that appears nowhere on the panel, starting with the reason you started. If the list is short, that's the work for this quarter.

Diana Shams Diana Shams Founder & Perception Architect, Renuvo Design Inc.
Renuvo Design Inc. Talk to Diana Brand Diagnostic
01Product
02Gap
03Diagnosis
04Next Step